TalkTalk vs Sky broadband: the same Openreach line from two companies, one of which cannot tell you whether you can leave

Which one to choose

Direct answer: Sky, for most households, on price and on the right to leave: Sky is the cheaper of the two at all three speeds where both sell something comparable, by £2 a month at the entry tier and £7 at 900 Mbps. Choose TalkTalk if you would rather know the whole two years than save the difference, because TalkTalk prints both future April prices beside every tier and Sky prints none. TalkTalk will tell you exactly what you pay for the next two years and will not tell you whether you can leave if it sells you on. Sky will not tell you what you pay next April and states plainly, in its Chief Operating Officer's words, that a price rise sets you free.

That is the answer, and the rest of this page is the working. It is worth saying at the top what this comparison is not about. These two sell the same Openreach line to the same house, so the cable in the ground is not what you are choosing between. What you are choosing is a company: its price, its contract, its customer service and, on this pairing unusually, whether it will still be your provider in a year.

One thing on this page is unusual enough that we should say where it came from. We went looking for TalkTalk's prices and found, on TalkTalk's own help centre, a question the company sets itself and does not answer. The silence is the finding, and it is TalkTalk's own help centre that makes it one. Asked whether a customer can decline the move to Rise Fibre, TalkTalk answers without using the words cancel, notice or early termination charge. Asked the same question about a different transfer, on the same help centre, it answers that you are free to move providers with no early termination fee. Two answers to one question, from one company. None of that means a TalkTalk customer has been charged a penny more. Both transfer pages say the price and the contract carry over unchanged, and we have seen nothing to suggest otherwise. The complaint is about what was not said, not about what was done.

Run your address through our comparison before you decide between two brands, read our full TalkTalk review and our full Sky review for either one on its own, and how we rank deals explains why we compare on the average across a term rather than on the headline.

The same line, so what are you actually choosing?

Direct answer: Both run over the same Openreach line to the same house, so the cable in the ground is not what you are choosing between. The speed, the reliability and the engineer are Openreach's on both. What you are actually choosing is a price, a contract and a customer service department. The same fibre reaches 23.4 million premises as at 30 June 2026, and a dozen retailers sell over it besides these two.

This matters more than it sounds, because it removes most of the things people think they are comparing. The speed is Openreach's. The reliability is Openreach's. The engineer who comes to the house works for Openreach. If your neighbour is on the other brand, the two of you are on the same physical connection and, at a matched tier, the same advertised speed.

There is one exception on TalkTalk's side. TalkTalk sells the same tiers over Openreach and over CityFibre at the same price, and publishes no way to tell which you would get short of checking a postcode. Sky sells over Openreach and nothing else. So at a CityFibre address the two are not quite on the same line, though TalkTalk prices them identically and does not tell you which you are getting.

Our guide to which network your provider uses explains how to tell, and the technology guide covers what each network type actually delivers.

What each one costs today

Direct answer: Sky is the cheaper of the two at all three speeds where both sell something comparable, by £2 a month at the entry tier and £7 at 900 Mbps. Both sell the same download speed at each of those tiers, because both are reselling the same line, so at a matched tier the cheaper one is simply cheaper.

Two tiers sit outside that table because the other side sells nothing comparable. TalkTalk's Full Fibre 65 is £26 a month, and Sky's 2.5 Gigafast+ is £32 for 2,500 Mbps both ways, which Sky sells to 12% of UK homes. Note what the first of those does to TalkTalk's own ladder: Full Fibre 150 is a pound cheaper than the slower Full Fibre 65, so on TalkTalk's ladder the entry speed is not the entry price. Check both before you pick the cheaper sounding one.

On set-up both charge nothing. TalkTalk prints “No setup fee” on every tier card. Sky advertises £0 with small print that says a fee “£9.95 router delivery plus £10 activation” may be required, which is the less helpful of the two ways to say the same thing. TalkTalk advertised no gift card, voucher or cashback on any page we read on 21 September 2026. Sky was advertising up to £200 of switching credit, which pays back what your old provider charges you to leave rather than discounting the price.

One date to watch if you are reading this later: £23 on Sky Full Fibre 150 was marked as available until 23 September 2026, and £27 on Full Fibre 500 until 14 October 2026. TalkTalk printed no end date against any of its four prices, which is the more useful way round.

Our price and contract checker totals any deal across its term, our hand-checked deals table carries every figure with the date it was verified, and the cheapest deals ranks the whole market on the average across a term.

The next two years, where TalkTalk tells you and Sky does not

Direct answer: This is the column TalkTalk wins outright. It prints a sentence like this beside every tier: “Increasing to £29 from April 2027 then to £33 in April 2028.” Sky prints nothing of the kind beside any of its four prices. On this pairing the disclosure runs the opposite way to the price. Sky is cheaper today and tells you nothing about tomorrow. TalkTalk costs more today and tells you exactly what it will cost for the next two years.

TalkTalk's rule is simple and it is published: “From 16 November 2025 we're changing our annual price increases on broadband plans to a flat rate of £4.” Any planned increases will be applied each April, starting in 2026. Two older cohorts are still running on different terms, £3 a month for contracts from 12 August 2024 to 15 November 2025 and CPI plus 3.7% for anything older. There is a fourth case worth knowing: A customer who joined before 12 August 2024 and is out of contract also gets the £4 increase.

TalkTalk's two-year total can be worked out from its own published prices, because it prints both future April prices beside every tier: £696 at Full Fibre 150, £816 at 500 and £960 at 900. Sky's cannot, at any tier, because Sky has not published next April's increase or the one after. Sky sets its increase afresh each year and announces it six to eight weeks ahead, so there is no future price to read at the point of sale. That is not a small difference in a two-year purchase, and on a page where the cheaper provider is Sky it is the strongest single argument for the other one.

We should say plainly that TalkTalk's approach here is the better practice, because this site spends a good deal of its time asking providers to do exactly this. A price you can read for the whole term is worth more than a price that is lower today and unknowable in April. Whether it is worth £2 to £7 a month is the question only you can answer, and the next section is the reason it is not quite that simple.

Our guide to mid-contract price rises sets out every large provider's rule side by side, and what happens when your contract ends covers the step after the term.

Who you are buying from, and whether that stays true

Direct answer: TalkTalk has published two transfers of its own consumer customers to other companies during 2026, and its parent company's most recent published statement says a formal process to explore disposal options is underway. Everything in this section is quoted from the companies' own pages or taken from Companies House.

Start with what the parent company has said. On 2 March 2026, announcing £115m of new funding facilities, TalkTalk Group said: “As previously announced, the Group has appointed advisers in response to inbound interest from potential acquirers of parts of the group. A formal process to explore disposal options is underway.” Read that wording carefully, because it says parts of the group rather than naming the consumer business, and TalkTalk has not published which parts. TalkTalk Group has published nothing in its newsroom since that statement. Companies House shows no change of ownership. The confirmation statement TalkTalk Group filed on 13 March 2026, eleven days after that announcement, is recorded as made with no updates.

Then what has actually happened to customers. TalkTalk's own help centre says: “Your broadband contract transferred to Rise Fibre on 1 August 2026.” It adds: “Your existing contract and any remaining minimum term will continue to apply following the transfer to Rise Fibre.” And on the money: “No changes are being made to your monthly broadband charge because of the transfer. Your price and the terms of your contract will remain the same.” A month later a second group moved, and for that one the published account is the receiving company's: “Your home phone and/or broadband account, previously looked after by TalkTalk's consumer division, is moving to Fleur Telecom from 1st September 2026. This is simply a change to who manages and bills your account, and your service runs over the same network as today.” Fleur adds: “Your price stays the same. Same package, same price, same network, no interruption to your connection.” TalkTalk itself has published no customer-facing page about the Fleur Telecom transfer that we could find, so the only published account of it is Fleur's.

None of that means a TalkTalk customer has been charged a penny more. Both transfer pages say the price and the contract carry over unchanged, and we have seen nothing to suggest otherwise. The complaint is about what was not said, not about what was done. It is also worth being clear about what this page will not tell you. Neither company has published how many customers moved in either transfer, and TalkTalk has published no current figure for its debt, its losses or how many customers it has. Figures for all of these circulate in the trade press. None is published by anybody who would know, later reporting has already revised two of them, and none appears on this page. TalkTalk Group's last filed accounts are made up to 28 February 2025, and the next set is not due until 30 November 2026.

Sky's side of this section is short, which is rather the point. Sky is part of a group that publishes, has announced no sale of its broadband business, and has not transferred its customers to anyone. There is nothing to report, and on a two-year contract that absence is worth something.

Our guide to what happens to your contract when a provider is bought or sold covers the general case, and One Touch Switch covers leaving under your own steam.

Can you leave, and when

Direct answer: On Sky yes, on TalkTalk no, and it is the same mechanism read in two directions. The provider that will not tell you next April's price is the one that has to let you go when it arrives. The provider that tells you is the one that can hold you to it.

Read the second, third and fourth rows together, because that is the trade in three lines. TalkTalk can tell you what April 2027 and April 2028 cost precisely because it has tied itself to a number, and tying itself to that number is what removes your right to walk when it lands. Sky can tell you nothing, and that uncertainty is exactly what hands you the exit. Neither is the generous position. They are two different bets about what a customer wants.

On leaving early, TalkTalk is the more transparent of the two again: a published rate, £11.25 a month for every month left on a full fibre contract, plus 30 days' notice, and a worked example on its own page. Sky publishes a method rather than a rate, so you cannot work out in advance what leaving would cost you. That is a real point for TalkTalk and it sits oddly beside the section above it, where the one thing TalkTalk would not spell out was how to leave.

Our guide to leaving when the price goes up covers the rule, and how early exit fees are calculated covers the sum.

The scoreboards, and where they disagree

Direct answer: Sky wins the headline measure and it is not close: Ofcom logged 5 broadband complaints per 100,000 for Sky against 10 for TalkTalk, and the highest of any broadband provider, above the industry average of 6 and above Vodafone (8), BT (7), Virgin Media and EE (6), Sky (5) and Plusnet (4), and the only broadband figure Ofcom does not declare statistically comparable to any other provider. But two of Ofcom's own service measures go the other way, and they are worth reading before you conclude the case is closed.

The two rows that break the pattern are the interesting ones. TalkTalk answers the telephone in 1 minute 8 seconds against Sky's 2 minutes 17 seconds, and fewer of its customers had a reason to complain at all, 23% against 26%. Put those beside a complaints rate twice Sky's and you get a picture worth stating: TalkTalk's customers are no more likely to have a problem and get through faster when they do, but the problems that do arise are far more likely to end up in front of the regulator. Getting answered quickly is not the same as getting sorted.

Two caveats on that table, both of which cut against leaning on it too hard. Those four measures are Ofcom's newest published service-quality set and they describe 2024, so they are two years older than the complaints figures above them. And Ofcom's report does publish an overall satisfaction figure for Sky. We could not read it reliably enough to print it, so this row is deliberately blank rather than guessed.

One more thing Ofcom publishes about only one of these two. Both have signed Ofcom's residential broadband speed code, so both owe you a guaranteed minimum speed and a way out if it is missed. Both are also in Ofcom's automatic compensation scheme, but Ofcom prints a restriction beside one name and no other: “TalkTalk (restrictions apply for customers not on the Openreach network).” If your TalkTalk line runs over CityFibre rather than Openreach, that caveat is about you, and TalkTalk does not tell you which you are on.

Our provider hub puts every company's scores side by side, and how to complain covers the process if it goes wrong.

The speed promises, and the one that covers a single tier

Direct answer: Both have signed Ofcom's residential broadband speed code, so both owe you a guaranteed minimum speed and a way out if it is missed. What each publishes in advance is very different. TalkTalk publishes a guaranteed minimum speed for one tier only, 725 Mbps on Full Fibre 900, and publishes none for Full Fibre 65, 150 or 500. Sky publishes a figure for the line at your address rather than for the product.

Sky's wording: “We guarantee the broadband speed to your hub will not fall below your Guaranteed Minimum Download Speed for at least 3 days in a row in a 30-day period” TalkTalk's: TalkTalk's speed promise is the same shape as BT's: if the speed stays below the guaranteed minimum and TalkTalk cannot fix it, you may leave without penalty.

The row worth pausing on is the fifth. TalkTalk's own two pages do not agree on how long it gets to fix it: the help centre says thirty working days and the terms of use say thirty days. A promise whose cure period depends on which TalkTalk page you read is a weaker promise than one number consistently stated, and it is the sort of thing you only discover at the moment you need it.

On Wi-Fi the gap is plain. TalkTalk publishes no Wi-Fi guarantee at all: no promised speed in a room, no remedy and no credit. Sky's WiFi Max is from £6 a month and promises Wi-Fi in every room or your money back. Neither is a reason to buy on its own, but if your house is the kind where the back bedroom never worked, only one of these two has written anything down about it.

Our guide to minimum guaranteed download speeds explains what each promise is worth, whether poor speeds let you leave early covers the remedy, and our speed test records what you are actually getting with a timestamp.

The social tariffs, where one of them has nothing at all

Direct answer: TalkTalk is the only one of the large providers absent from Ofcom's list of social tariffs. Sky runs one, and it comes with a condition that rules out most of the people who would go looking for it.

Sky Broadband Basics is £20 a month, or £24 on the faster plans from 17 September 2026, on a 24 months contract, for a household on Universal Credit, Pension Credit, Income Support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance or income-based Employment and Support Allowance. Then the condition: “Our Sky Broadband Basics offer is only available if you already have Sky Broadband with us” If you are not already a Sky Broadband customer, the route in is a telephone call rather than an online order: “If you don't already have Sky Broadband, get in touch with us.”

Two things in Sky's favour and one against. It comes with a new 24-month contract, but if you need to leave us before it ends, we won't charge you any early termination fees on your Sky Broadband. And Sky froze the price again this year: “our broadband social tariff will once again be frozen” Against it, Sky will not say where the price lands afterwards: “After 24-months the price will go back to the standard rate. We'll tell you what this will be when you get in touch to take Sky Broadband Basics.”

TalkTalk's position is simpler and worse. TalkTalk is the only one of the large providers absent from Ofcom's list of social tariffs. We checked its own site again on 21 September 2026, including the page it aims at pensioners, and found no low-income tariff, no means-tested discount and no benefits-related pricing anywhere. On a qualifying benefit this is not a comparison between these two: it is a reason to look at the rest of the market.

Ofcom's own list is where to start, because 33 providers run one and the cheapest in the market is £12.50 a month. A household on a qualifying benefit will almost always do better with a provider from that list than with either of the two on this page.

Our social tariff guide lists every provider's tariff with its price and who qualifies, and the cheapest deals covers the open market for anyone who does not qualify.

What else comes with each

Direct answer: Both charge nothing to set up and both run 24-month terms. TalkTalk includes network-level filtering at no extra cost and publishes both its future prices. Sky includes a landline on every package and was advertising switching credit where TalkTalk was advertising nothing.

The landline row is a quiet win for Sky: “All our broadband services are inclusive of landline rental and Sky Pay As You Talk (£0pm) as standard” On TalkTalk, existing customers only, so a new customer who wants a home phone cannot simply add one. If you still use a landline, that is a real difference rather than a line item.

The security row goes the other way. TalkTalk's HomeSafe filters at the network rather than on each device and costs nothing, which is a genuinely useful thing to include on a family connection. Sky sells its equivalents as part of the TV and Wi-Fi extras rather than including them with broadband.

Our guide to exit fees and setup fees compares the cost at both ends of a contract, and switching broadband covers One Touch Switch from both ends.

Who should choose which

Direct answer: Sky on price, on complaints and on the exit. TalkTalk on disclosure, on upload and on getting through to somebody. Most households will land on Sky, and the ones who should not are the ones who value knowing the whole bill more than paying the smaller one.

Rows three and four are the same question asked twice, and on this pairing they are the tie-break for most people. TalkTalk suits the household that wants to sign once, know the number and not think about it again. Sky suits the household that will open the letter when it arrives. Whichever you pick, write down what you are paying and when the term ends, because on this pairing the company billing you in two years may not be the company you signed with.

The third option this page would otherwise hide

Direct answer: On an Openreach line the choice is never only these two: the same cable carries a dozen other retailers, and the cheapest of them is usually cheaper than both. On our own table of 373 deals from 28 providers, read on 1 September 2026, entry prices ran between £23 and £34 a month with a median of £28, and the cheapest was £13.50 a month (4th Utility, 150 Mbps on CityFibre).

On this pairing that caveat is stronger than usual, because there is nothing physical keeping you with either. Both are reselling the same Openreach line, so a third retailer on that same line delivers the identical connection, from the identical network, fixed by the identical engineer, and several of them charge less than either of these two. A head-to-head page implies the choice is between the two names in the title. Here, it genuinely is not.

What the two on this page have that some cheaper rivals do not: both are in Ofcom's automatic compensation scheme and both have signed the speed code, which several budget retailers have not. For a lot of households those safety nets are worth a pound or two a month. But it should be a decision you make rather than one the page makes for you, which is why the comparison below is not filtered to these two alone.

Run the full comparison to see every provider at your address, or start from the cheapest deals, full fibre from every network or social tariffs.

TalkTalk and Sky deals at your postcode